Library closure consultation 'a sham' says campaigner

But council strongly denies that any final decision has been made

Dan Cooper


Dan Cooper


01635 886632

Protestors march against library closure proposals

WEST Berkshire Council has hit back at claims that it has already made a decision about the future of its libraries.

As previously reported in the Newbury Weekly News, the council is proposing to close eight of the district’s nine libraries as part of its second phase of cuts to public services.

Two weeks ago, the district council held a behind-closed-doors meeting with representatives of the parishes whose libraries are under threat.

In a letter published in this week’s NWN, anti-cuts campaigner Carolyne Culver says: “According to report backs from the meeting, parish councillors were advised to form resident charitable trusts to take control of the running of their libraries.

“This is despite the fact that the formal West Berkshire Council public consultation about proposed library closures still had one week to run. This exposes the consultation as a sham.”

The council vehemently denied those claims and said the option of charitable trusts was “simply an example of how a parish council or other community group might consider running their own library if the option to do so came about”.

It added: “We strongly disagree with any suggestion the consultation has been a sham.”

Ms Culver’s letter adds: “Representatives of the residents’ campaigns to prevent library closures were not invited, and neither were parish councillors or residents from areas that use the mobile libraries.

“Councillor Hilary Cole’s [who set up the meeting] excuse was that this would be ‘unwieldy and unproductive’.”

The council said the invite was narrowed to “ensure a manageable discussion”.

Councillor Cole added: “Since we began our consultation we’ve always been clear that we want to work with our communities to explore with them new ways in which we might deliver a range of services currently offered by the council.

“Last week I met with town and parish councils to try and get a better idea about how much interest they have in running their local library and different ways that might be achieved.

“It was our opportunity for us to explore together some different ideas for the future but no decisions were made.”

The final decision on whether to close libraries will be made on March 24.

Leave your comment

Share your opinions on Newbury Weekly News

Characters left: 1000

Article comments

  • SimonKirby


    12/03/2016 - 09:09

    The idea of community charitable trusts supported by their parish council in running local libraries is a decent enough idea but it is pretty radical and has little precedent in providing libraries, but it is precisely the model under which half of the country's allotment sites are run. Now Newbury Town Council, the biggest of West Berkshire's parish councils, runs its own allotment service, and a very expensive operation this is once you've contracted out the grounds maintenance and paid for all of that Town-Hall administration.so rather than thinking about an exotic arrangement whereby a community trust runs the parish's libraries a better solution is for a community trust to run the parish's allotment service and for the money saved to be put towards the council's running of the libraries.



Woman taken to hospital following M4 collision

Woman taken to hospital following M4 collision

Emergency services called to three-vehicle collision last night (Friday)

Dancing the night away to Diwali

Dancing the night away to Diwali

More than 450 people join in celebrations at Newbury Racecourse


Pudsey Bear pays visit to Newbury fundraiser


Go ahead for back garden development in Thatcham


Severe weather warning issued for Saturday